Monthly Archives: January 2011

no_photo

Todgarh Social Audit

PRESS RELEASE

Todgarh Social Audit endorses district administration findings of Rs 56 lakh embezzlement

Abhiyan demands governmental enquiry of entire block

Jaipur, January 7, 2011: The social audit of development works under MGNREGA in Todgarh panchayat, Ajmer district asserted and endorsed the Rs 56 lakh embezzlement found by the district administration in a recent enquiry, whose findings were read out at the social audit gram sabha yesterday. It may be recalled that only recently, panchayat resident Bikam Chand Jain who was seeking information  on MGNREGA and other panchayat works in Todgarh had his legs cut off by relatives of the ex-sarpanch and is currently undergoing treatment in Mumbai. Significantly, corruption to the tune of Rs 1.3 crore was also uncovered by a special audit of MGNREGA works last year in neighbouring panchayat Malaton ki Vair.

“The scale of fraud being unearthed in these two neighbouring panchayats and the violent attack on information seekers indicates there is rampant corruption in this area. We demand that an enquiry of the entire block be done,” said Nikhil Dey of Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS).

Chairperson of the social audit committee Tej Singh pointed out that while water conservation works had been sanctioned for 5 years, only Rs 24 lakh for one year had been shown as expenditure by the panchayat, and even here, the social audit team found that only Rs 1 lakh of work had been actually done. Irregularities in muster rolls, fake names, works done in places other than where sanctioned were also uncovered by the social audit team.

Tej Singh also informed those present that there was a discrepancy in the amount of expenditure shown on the wall painting and the actual records. While only an amount of Rs 60.19 lakh had been shown on the walls, the actual expenditure in 2009-10 stood at Rs 1.95 crore.

However, the Todgarh social audit is also significant as it brought out the weaknesses of the social process done by the social audit committee without any technical support or ‘outside’ intervention ever since the central government amended the social audit clause 13b in theMGNREG Act.

When the chairperson of the social audit committee Tej Singh got up to read the findings of the social audit team initially, the Additional CEO, Zila Parishad Ajmer signaled to the additional tehsildar to read out the findings of the district administration’s report instead and take note of any objections. Thereafter, the entire proceedings was conducted by the government officers rather than the social audit team members.

The social audit gram sabha was attended by members of the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, SR Abhiyan and 14 IAS trainees from the IAS Academy, Mussoorie  as observers.

Mukesh Goswami /Sowmya Sivakumar

(on behalf of the Abhiyan)


News articles about the Todgarh Social Audit:

Rural Jobs Social Audit Confirms Fraud, The Hindu

Fraud in Accounts Confirmed, Times of India

MNREGA Verification

Statement by the MKSS on reports of intimidation being faced by Teesta Setalvad and others

“We are extremely concerned and distressed to hear reports that Teesta Setalvad, Advocate MM Tirmizi and others are being victimised for their steadfast effort to take judicial proceedings against the perpetrators of the communal riots that took place in Gujarat in 2002 to their logical conclusion. We are very disturbed to hear that they fear for their lives and are anxious for their safety. It is very unfortunate that the very State that should be offering them protection and should see them as partners in ensuring justice is done, is harassing them. We urge the government in the strongest possible way to ensure that no harm through malicious intent comes their way.

The trial on the 2002 Gujarat communal riots is near its end and so this harassment has clearly been timed to intimidate the ‘Citizens for Peace and Justice’ who have been fighting for the victims. One must also take cognisance of the fact that similar to the unjustified persecution of Binayak Sen, this also seems to be an attempt to pass a message to others not to come out in support of human rights and victims of injustice. The conviction of Binayak Sen for sedition and treason, has implications well beyond the State of Chhattisgarh. That voices of dissent are being forcefully stamped out by the State through such coercive means and intimidation in different States in India shows the need for vigilance across the country to protect activists human rights defenders, and democracy itself.”

Signed,

Aruna Roy, Nikhil Dey, Shankar Singh and Bhanwar Meghwanshi

For the MKSS